Most website advice is a wish list. This one is a checklist. These are the 36 things our scanner looks at when it scores a business website, sorted into five areas, with what "done" looks like for each.
Everything here can be checked from the outside, in minutes. You do not need your analytics or a developer to see where you stand. Want it done for you? Our free 36-point website score runs every check on your site in under a minute.
How the score works
- Each area gets a score: the share of its checks that are in place. Half done counts as half.
- Your overall score is the average of the five areas, so a weak area pulls everything down.
- A check that does not apply is left out, not failed. An online-only business is not marked down for having no tap-to-call number or Google Maps link.
1. Website basics and speed (4 checks)
- Secure connection. The address starts with https and shows the padlock.
- Opens quickly on a phone. Ideally a Google PageSpeed mobile score of 90 or more. At the very least, the server answers in under a second and a half.
- Fits phone screens. The page is built for mobile, not shrunk down from desktop.
- The home page is light. Under about 250 KB of page code. Heavy builders and stacked plugins slow everything down.
2. Google and AI search (12 checks)
- The page title says what you do and where. "Roof repair in Ottawa | Northside Roofing", 15 to 65 characters.
- A short description for Google results, 70 to 170 characters, written for a person.
- Enough words for Google to read. At least 300 words on the home page.
- One clear headline. Exactly one main heading (H1) on the home page.
- Questions and answers AI assistants can quote, marked up as FAQ data.
- Business details labelled for Google and AI (schema.org data: name, address, phone, hours).
- AI assistants are allowed in. Your robots.txt does not block GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot or Google-Extended.
- A sitemap at yourdomain/sitemap.xml.
- Shared links show a preview with a title and image (Open Graph tags).
- Images have descriptions (alt text) on at least 80% of them.
- A plain summary for AI assistants at yourdomain/llms.txt.
- The main version of each page is marked with a canonical tag.
Most business sites we scan lose the most points here. The good news: these are one-time fixes.
3. Social and reputation (3 checks)
- The website links to your social profiles.
- You are on at least two platforms and both are linked.
- Your Google Business Profile is linked from the site (local businesses only).
4. Security and email (6 checks)
- Email on your own domain, not a free address.
- SPF record: only the services you approve can send email as you.
- DMARC set to quarantine or reject, so fake emails in your name get blocked. Our email spam checker writes the records for you.
- HSTS: browsers always use the secure version of your site.
- Standard protections on (the X-Content-Type-Options header).
- Other sites cannot frame yours (X-Frame-Options or frame-ancestors).
5. Turning visitors into leads (11 checks)
- One clear call to action on the home page: book, call, get a quote.
- Contact in one step from the home page: tap-to-call, a form, chat or booking, not just a link to a contact page.
- A contact or booking form on the site.
- Tap-to-call phone number (local businesses).
- The call to action sits near the top.
- The wording says what happens next. "Get my free quote" beats "Submit" and "Learn more".
- Proof on the home page: reviews, client logos or a guarantee.
- A short form: five fields or fewer.
- One main action, not many. Three different button wordings at most.
- The call to action repeats lower down for people who scroll.
- Visitor tracking installed, so you can see what works.
What we leave out on purpose
Review counts, posting habits and how fast you answer enquiries all matter, but you cannot see them from a website, so they are not guessed. Same for conversion rates: those need your own numbers.
Fix them in this order
- Leads first. A fast site with no clear next step still loses the customer.
- Then Google and AI search. Most fixes take an afternoon and keep paying.
- Then email security. Fifteen minutes in your domain settings stops people faking your email.
- Speed and the rest last, unless your site is truly slow on a phone.
You are a website consultant for small businesses. I will paste the results of a website checklist for my business. Turn it into a fix plan I can hand to my web person. My business: [type of business] in [city], [online only / local customers]. My website runs on: [Wix / Squarespace / WordPress / Shopify / not sure]. For every check that is missing or partly done: 1. Explain in one plain sentence why it costs me customers. 2. Give the exact steps to fix it on my platform. If you are not sure of a menu name, say so. 3. Estimate the time: under 15 minutes, about an hour, or needs a developer. Order the list: lead and call-to-action fixes first, then Google and AI search, then email security, then speed. Canadian English, no jargon without a short explanation. Checklist results: [paste the results here]
Want it done for you?
Run the free 36-point website score to see your own list, or book a call and we will fix the gaps for you, usually inside a week.